The Ghost Map: The Story of London’s Most Terrifying Epidemic–and How It Changed Science, Cities, and the Modern World
Posted by admin | Posted in Infectious Disease | Posted on 11-08-2010
5
- ISBN13: 9781594482694
- Condition: New
- Notes: BUY WITH CONFIDENCE, Over one million books sold! 98% Positive feedback. Compare our books, prices and service to the competition. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Product Description
A National Bestseller, a New York Times Notable Book, and an Entertainment Weekly Best Book of the Year
It’s the summer of 1854, and London is just emerging as one of the first modern cities in the world. But lacking the infrastructure-garbage removal, clean water, sewers-necessary to support its rapidly expanding population, the city has become the perfect breeding ground for a terrifying disease no one knows how to cure. As the cholera outbreak takes hold, a physician and a local curate are spurred to action-and ultimately solve the most pressing medical riddle of their time.
In a triumph of multidisciplinary thinking, Johnson illuminates the intertwined histories of the spread of disease, the rise of cities, and the nature of scientific inquiry, offering both a riveting history and a powerful explanation of how it has shaped the world we live in.
email2friend
I just finished Steven Johnson’s “Ghost Map”. Not to be rude, but how does this stuff get published? For Pete’s sake, the name of the book is ghost map, and there is not even a copy of the ghost map in the book.
The book itself lacks any kind of literary punch. Ostensibly about John Snow and cholera, in which there is probably an interesting story if told with focus, Johnson rambles pointlessly around campy urban planning doggerel.
I guess Johnson’s reputation is so unassailable that editors don’t bother to read what they publish. And that is what the book lacks, an editor.
The worst part is Johnson’s attack on the foolish orthodoxy of the miasmaists, while he dutifully regurgitates the junior-high platitudes to Darwinist orthodoxy, when doing so adds absolutely nothing to the story, except to confirm his own Party loyalty.
Rating: 1 / 5
I haven’t read this book, but if you want a stellar historical novel on times of plague (16th century England this time), read Geraldine Brooks _Year of Wonders_. Not only is it absolutely riveting, but it is beautifully and meticulously written, with unforgettable characters. You will not be able to put it down, and it will stay with you for a long time. It is easily one of the best books I’ve ever read.
Rating: 4 / 5
The story is fascinating and informative, but has a few places where the writing style comes across as a bit amateurish. Also, I was expecting a more forceful ending. Overall, a fun, worthwhile read, but without a punch.
Rating: 3 / 5
Book reviews, it seems, come in two forms… one is to consider the writing of a book and the other is to consider a book’s content. In the case of Johnson’s The Ghost Map, I found his writing very comfortable and an easy read. In fact, the sort of writing which tends to constrain a person from putting the book down. In a way, the book is much like a Colombo mystery; i.e. we know the culprit but enjoy the journey to expose him. I believe Johnson is to be commended for his effort, bringing an important time of scientific discovery to the modern reader. It may be fair enough to say that few young readers today are aware of John Snow (as well as others) and his work to determine the cause of the cholera epidemic which stuck London in mid 19th century. What is sad about this deadly event, and sad that Johnson didn’t touch upon it, is that humanity had been told many years earlier about the proper way to care for human waste. The message of Deuteronomy 23: 12-14… is pretty clear but, apparently, this message was not honored. Had someone truly honored what God told the Hebrew children about human waste, perhaps many of the deaths in London and elsewhere could have been prevented. What John Snow (re)discovered was the truth of what had been told years earlier to the Hebrews as they left Egypt. Johnson didn’t even mention this in his account.
I believe Johnson, otherwise, has done a good job but he could have done better if had not included so much nonsense about evolution. He tends to believe organic evolution is a real thing but to date no evidence has been put on the table to prove it….just a bunch of words.
Nevertheless, given these concerns, I recommend Johnson’s book.. for it shows, if nothing else, how an incorrect idea (Miasma) can hinder the progress of science. We see much of this same blindness in today’s schools where the silliness of evolution is the reigning paradigm.
Rating: 4 / 5
A fan of books by historical writers such as Erik Larson (“Isaac’s Storm,” “Devil in the White City”) and Timothy Egan (the utterly breathtaking “The Worst Hard Time”), I decided to give Steven Johnson a try. Needless to say, I was disappointed in “The Ghost Map.” Johnson quite simply did not leave an impression on me the way Larson and Egan did. The book seemed too moralistic and preachy, relying on pathos and storytelling as much, if not more than, actual, historical fact. There are too many descriptions of babies crying in dark, empty homes; too many forced diatribes of ideological battles between Snow and Whitehead; too many far-fetched extrapolations to the present and future for the book to function effectively. But perhaps the most glaring issue is that many of the winding, senselessly repetitive passages had no historical basis whatsoever, and if they did, Johnson certainly did not convey the connection to his sources clearly. Had I submitted this as a paper for class, I would expect much of it to be returned underneath layers and layers of disheartening red ink. Johnson’s bibliography is respectable, but his final product is not. Rarely do I encounter a book where I feel as though I am wasting my time. Sadly, “Ghost Map” falls into that category. All I wanted to do was set the book down write to Penguin Books for a refund. I hoped Johnson might eventually resurrect himself, and therefore kept reading–a mistake indeed. The only enjoyable part of the novel was the beginning, when Johnson described the thousands of scavengers sifting through London’s filth. After that, the book spun wildly… not downhill (because that would imply a sense of direction), but every which way imaginable. “The Ghost Map” is history at its sensationalized worst. Although I have not read Sandra Hempel’s “The Strange Case of the Broad Street Pump,” I feel obligated to recommend it before I even consider suggesting this piece.
Rating: 1 / 5